Categories: NFL Draft

Will McDonald IV Scouting Report: A Unique and Exciting EDGE

Will McDonald IV is a unique prospect with many exciting traits but also a few downsides. He is a late riser and someone who didn’t break onto the scene until his redshirt Senior year. He had some impressive production early in his career before he dropped off in 2020. You’d like to see a more consistent career, but he has all the traits to become a dominant player. One of the reasons he’s so unique is he played out of position as a 4/5 technique. McDonald is meant to play true EDGE, where he can utilize his explosiveness and bend. He showed off his elite skills at the Senior Bowl, where he faced legit competition. There are some red flags, but overall, he leaves other analysts and me excited to see him in the pros.

Two all-22 games and two more regular games were evaluated. This scouting report includes grades on all relevant traits based on his film. His scouting report also factored in stats and analytics, such as PFF grades. Use promo code TREYSCHNEIDER on Underdog Fantasy to match your deposit up to $100. Please gamble responsibly and leave your feedback on Twitter @FBIntellect.

~5-minute read:

Profile
7th EDGE / 1-2 RD   |   6’3 / 239   |   Class – RS-SR  |   College – Iowa State
Pro Comparison
Randy Gregory
Scheme
3-4/ Any

D-line Stats

2022:

PR – 25

SK – 6

TKL – 37

TFL – 7.5

2021:

PR – 45

SK – 13

TKL – 36

TFL – 13

Clip Analysis

In this clip above, McDonald IV wins with speed and bend to get the sack. He lines up over the tackle and gives an initial club with his left hand before finishing with bend.

Here he wins with a swim move after engaging with the O-lineman. He first gives him a stutter before engaging, and then he swims over with his left hand.

He shows off his lethal spin move at the Senior Bowl in this tweet.

Grades

Traits/ Skills (see bottom of the page for scale)

Each trait/attribute is graded 1-7.

TraitsImmediatePotential
SPD5.85.8
ACC6.26.2
AGI5.25.4
STR4.85.2
SIZ5.66
GET5.46.6
BND5.86.2
IQ4.56
INS45.2
PWM3.45.4
FNM4.36
BKS3.85.2
TAC4.36
PUR5.26
COV45.5
EDGE KeyEDGE Key Cont.
SPD – Speed
ACC – Acceleration
AGI – Agility
STR – Strength
SIZ – Size/ Length
GET – Get-off
BND – Bend
IQ – Football IQ
INS – Instincts
PWM – Power Moves
FNM – Finesse Moves
BKS – Block Shedding
TAC – Tackling
PUR – Pursuit
COV – Coverage

Player Notes

Will McDonald IV Bio

  • Will McDonald IV is an explosive and bendy EDGE meant to play OLB but got stuck as a 4/5 technique. When he plays the proper role, his skills flourish. He is currently ranked 27th on The FBI 2023 Draft Board.

Pros

  • He made the “College Football Freaks List 2022” by Bruce Feldman and is expected to vertical jump 42 inches and broad jump 11 feet.
  • Has the arm-length of a hybrid defensive end – 35 inches, which is staggering.
  • An explosive first step with the bend to threaten outside with pure speed rush.
  • Has active and well-timed hands.
  • Strong and flexible lower half.
  • Flashes the ability to pull off counter moves.
  • Could develop a nasty cross-chop with more experience.
  • Showed off an outstanding spin move at the senior bowl multiple times.
  • Held his own in-run defense as a 4/5 technique.
  • Has the hot motor trait.
  • Could fit any scheme if he gains some weight.

Cons

  • His lack of mass will make him struggle at the point of attack.
  • He’s no Nolan Smith; he doesn’t have stellar play strength.
  • While his anchor is good in run defense, he doesn’t often disengage with blockers in run defense.
  • Isn’t great at converting speed to power
  • Doesn’t always get out of his stance quickly.
  • More of a straight-line runner.
  • He is a 24-year-old prospect come draft time.

Final Conclusion

Will McDonald IV is a prospect with first-round worthy traits, but his older age and poor development track are cause for red flags. There’s a shot he becomes a true number one pass rusher but is also equally as likely to fail. Overall, I like his game and will be rooting for him to succeed, as he’s a special type of athlete.

Combine

40 yd:

10 yd:

Shuttle:

3 cone:

Broad: 11’0″

Vertical: 36

Bench:

Arm Length: 34 7/8″

Hand Size:


Scales And Keys

Grading Key

POT – Potential: players’ highest upside

IMP – Impact: player’s immediate impact

Stats Key

PR – Pressures

SK – Sacks

TKL – Tackles

TFL – Tackles for loss

Draft Grade Formula
Age: 21-22:POT=(30%) IMP=(70%)
Age: 23-24:POT=(28%) IMP=(72%)
Age:-25+:POT=(26%) IMP=(74%)
Good/ bad character:POT=(+2%/-2%) IMP=(-2%/+2%)
Injury:POT=(-1%) in increments
OVR Grade Weight:
Pass Rush=75%
Run Defense=25%
Individual trait scale (1-7):
7 – Rare world-class skill; best in the league and no room for improvement   |   6 – Great-elite skill; one of the best at that given trait but still has some room to improve   |   5 – Very good; above average and has potential to be elite   |   4 – Average; able to suffice but, not ideal long-term   |   3 – Below average; able to suffice at college level   |   2 – Poor; hinders overall play and is a liability to the team   |   1 – Awful; not good enough to play given position at any level above D2 | Note: Consistency plays a large factor.
Overall Draft grade scale (15-100):
84 – Perfect prospect | 81 – Bluechip prospect | 80 – Likely all-pro | 79 – Day one quality starter or superstar potential | 78 – Day one starter w/ all-pro upside | 77 – Day one starter w/ high-end upside | 76 – Day One Starter | 75 – Boom or bust | 74 – Will become quality starter within 2-3 years | 73 – Boom or bust (high risk) | 72 – Will become starter within 2-3 years

Trey Schneider

Recent Posts

NFL Mock Draft 2025 1.0: Deshaun Watson is Replaced And The Giants Find a New Project QB

This NFL Mock Draft is a combination of what I think will happen and what…

1 week ago

WR Luther Burden III Prospect Deep Dive: Why The Playmaker is Perfect For a Shanahan Style Offense

Luther Burden III was at the top of everyone's draft boards entering the season. That…

3 weeks ago

RB Ashton Jeanty Prospect Deep Dive: How Can a Man be This Good at Football?

When I watched Bijan Robinson in the 2023 NFL draft, I genuinely believed he was…

1 month ago

SA Malaki Starks Prospect Deep Dive: A Rare Kind of Athlete With One Simple Flaw

Sometimes, you develop an instant crush when you watch an NFL prospect for the first…

2 months ago

QB Jalen Milroe Prospect Deep Dive: Is The Heisman Candidate a Legitimate Top-Ten Talent?

Before this current college season, I saw a decent bit of play from Jalen Milroe…

2 months ago

CB Will Johnson Prospect Deep Dive: Could The Former Five Star Be a True Lockdown Corner?

After Darrell Revis, the league hadn't seen a player with the pedigree of being a…

2 months ago

This website uses cookies.